Professor Raises Thoughtful Concerns about the Tainting of the Great American Pastime

September 13, 2007

Adjunct Associate Professor of Philosophy Kenneth Shouler, Ph.D. presented an audience of St. John’s University students, faculty and staff with interesting yet troubling statistics regarding the steroid controversy that has embroiled the world of professional baseball for the past few years.

Photo Gallery

Citing statistics that appear in his book Baseball Doubt, Baseball Certainty, Dr. Shouler points out that alleged steroid users are typically athletes who have passed the midpoint of their careers and are looking to enhance their productivity in the game for as long as possible. He believes that we need to keep this reality in mind and look harshly upon those athletes who use performance enhancing drugs to achieve success.

“Steroid users are cheaters” noted Shouler “and we need to strongly consider this when we evaluate a player’s performance.”

Shouler pointed out that baseball is more dependent upon numbers than most other sports, and that as fans we would do well to assign a “mental asterisk” to those numbers and records generated by players for whom steroid use has been alleged. He challenged the audience to compare the steroid-using players of today with the baseball greats of former years. “The true stars of baseball, such as Willie Mays, Mickey Mantle and Hank Aaron left the game better than they found it. Can anyone say that about the players alleged to have used steroids?”

Shouler believes that the game can recover from the steroid controversy but only if Major League Baseball sets the right example by strongly enforcing the rules that are already in place to deter players from succumbing to the lure of steroids. “If Major League Baseball and the owners continue to look the other way, this problem’s still going to be with us.”

“Baseball Doubt, Baseball Certainty” was the first of the 2007-2008 Academic Lecture Series, an ongoing series of informative presentations co-sponsored by the President’s Multicultural Advisory Committee, the Office of the Provost, Discover New York and Core Curriculum, the Department of Student Life and Student Government, Inc. For more information contact the Department of Student Life at (718) 990-6567 or view the brochure – Academic Lecture Series.